'Alex through the looking glass'

Alex through the looking glass: How life reflects numbers and numbers reflect life

by Alex Bellos

Alex Bellos' new book is an enjoyable tour of the fun bits of mathematics. Many of the topics will be familiar to readers of popular maths books — power laws, the number pi, the dispute between Newton and Liebniz about who first invented calculus, the invention of imaginary numbers, fractals, and so on. And even if some are common currency by now, Bellos has a knack of producing a pleasing "ah" when a concept is neatly explained, or when recounting an amusing anecdote. (My favourite was a grumpy Newton writing that he "does not love to be .. teezed by forreigners about mathematical things".)

For me, the most succesful and enjoyable chapters were actually those focussing on pure maths — such as the derivation of geometry from triangles, investigating curves created from conic sections, and the surprising complexities and subtleties of Conway's Game of Life. This is somewhat contrary to the subheading of the book "how life reflects numbers and how numbers reflect life". The best bits are those not so relevant to everyday life and are simply fascinating intellectual exercies by virtue of the way numbers and mathematics work. I believe readers likely to buy a book of this type might already find maths interesting enough, so there's no need to crowbar in the overwrought concepts of "relevance" and "everyday life"!

I have to admit, however, that I approached this book with a slight amount of trepidation. Bellos made a splash in the British media in mid-April with hot news of "the world's favourite number", which seemed to me to be a rather trivial revelation. Fortunately, the psychology of numbers only takes up the first chapter and Bellos makes the case that people's selection of favourites are interesting — people tend to pick prime numbers for significant and/or mystical numbers (like 7 and 13) and as also favourites higher up (for example 31, 41, 61, 71). However, quite interesting is about as far as it goes for this section — I still struggle to find it deeply interesting, and I felt actively quite annoyed by the consultant who will invent psychological reasons for why numbers are used by brands, such as Levis 501 and WD-40. This section, for me, strayed into the realms of pseudo-science — unprovable/disprovable claims about a cherry picked dataset whose answers are already known.

But despite these reservations, I did find Alex through the looking-glass a highly enjoyable read and something of a page turner! The complaints above are actually a small proportion of the overall book, so shouldn't outweigh the good in here.

One final thought — it would be nice to see a related website with links for further reading and YouTube clips of the exotic Conway Games of Life that are referred to. Much of the material presented is high-level and it's a credit to Bellos that one feels like looking at a topic of interest in more detail once he's introduced it, so it would be nice to have a destination for those follow-up investigations.

Book details:
Alex through the looking glass: How life reflects numbers and numbers reflect life
Alex Bellos
hardback — 352 pages
Bloomsbury Publishing (2014)
ISBN: 978-1408817773
 You can buy the book and help Plus at the same time by clicking on the link on the left to purchase from amazon.co.uk, and the link to the right to purchase from amazon.com. Plus will earn a small commission from your purchase.

About the author

Oli Freke is a London based composer and maths enthusiast. He is currently concerned with the number of possible melodies available to a composer using only 10 notes. He believes it’s over 21 billion — which is going to take a while to work through…

You can read about Sine Language, a piece he composed based on the maths of the sine wave, in a this Plus article.