Here are 19 dots arranged in a hexagon. Your task is to label the dots with the numbers 1 to 19 so that each set of three dots that lie along a straight-line segment add up to 22.
Happy puzzling!
(Download the grid to print and scribble on.)
Here's one solutions. If you have found others, or a good strategy for solving the puzzle, please let us know!
Some practical tips to help you when you need it most!
Want facts and want them fast? Our Maths in a minute series explores key mathematical concepts in just a few words.
As COP28, the 2023 United Nations Climate Change Conference, kicks off we look at how maths can help understand the climate crisis.
How do you create dramatic film out of mathematics? We find out with writer and director Timothy Lanzone.
Mathematics plays a central role in understanding how infectious diseases spread. This collection of articles looks at some basic concepts in epidemiology to help you understand this fascinating and important field, and set you up for further study.
Find out why the formula we use to work out conditional probabilities is true!
If x is the central dot, y1
If x is the central dot, y1 to y6 the dots participating in 3 lines, z1 to z12 the dots only participating in one line, and if A=y1+y2+y3+y4+y5+y6 and B=z1+z2+...+z12, then:
x+A+B=190 (the sum of all natural numbers from 1 to 19)
6x+3A+B=264 (the sum of all 12 lines with a sum of 22)
Therefore:
A=(74-5x)/2 (1)
B=(306+3x)/2 (2)
With x,A,B being natural numbers
Applying to x its possible values, i.e. 1,2,3,...,19 we have:
For x=1, A= 34,5 --> so x isn't 1
All odd values for x give the same result
For x=2, A=32 and B=168. We accept x=2, because in this case A has a minimum value of A=1+3+4+5+6+7=26
Same goes for x=4, since A=27 and B=159, with Amin=24
For x=6, A=22 and B=162, with Amin=22; x=6 is the last acceptable value for x, since:
for x=8, even though A and B are natural numbers, and therefore acceptable values, A < Amin and therefore x>8 is not an acceptable solution. Moreover, x has been shown to be an even number.
However, if x=6, one cannot find any solution when trying to solve the grid. Therefore, solutions are acceptable only if x=2 or x=4.
Love Anonymous' summing approach!
Beautiful approach. I got the 3 connections at each corner vertex, and 6 in the middle vertex, 1 for every other vertex, too. Then I went on to reason that 19 consists of 10 uneven and 9 even numbers, since 22 is even, and only three even numbers or two uneven and one even yield an even result, I went on to find a configuration on the grid, satisfying this. Which proved to be a tedious effort. However, convinced that this ought to be true, I didn't conceive of the summing up, which as presented by you, proves very elegant.
Thanks for such a logical explanation and method, these magic riddles often have a habit of getting me in a bad mood, for their lack of solving methodology.
A third solution
This post is from last year, I know, but I just recently discovered this webpage!
I found a third solution in addition to the two mentioned here. It has number 2 in the center and the numbers in the corners are (in clockwise order) 1,3,5,7,4,12.
After limiting down the center number to either 2 or 4 and thereafter checking different possibilities I found the three solutions now mentioned, and I do believe that these are the only possible ones.
One more...
In fact, there is one more with 2 in the middle, with vertices labelled (4,3,1,7,9,8).
So, recapitulating we have:
with 4 in the middle (6,2,1,3,10,5)
with 2 in the middle (4,3,1,7,9,8); (4,12,1,3,5,7); (5,3,1,8,4,11)
And I think that is!
Best
I used the fact that 22 is
I used the fact that 22 is composed of either: 2 odds and 1 even OR 3 evens, mapping that on the grid meant putting an even in the middle and the having 2 all even radii and 4 of 2 odds and one even. filling in lead to the first solution. doesn't give you a repeatable method but hey ho
Magic 19
Look closely: There are 15 sets of 3 dots that lie along a straight line making the puzzle unsolvable as far as i can see.