How should offices and other indoor spaces be ventilated to keep people safe from COVID-19? A recent paper by mathematicians at the University of Cambridge has some answers — and shows that wearing masks does make a difference.
See here for all our coverage of the COVID-19 pandemic.
"As winter approaches in the northern hemisphere and people start spending more time inside, understanding the role of ventilation is critical to estimating the risk of contracting the virus and helping slow its spread," says Paul Linden, who wrote the paper along with Rajesh Bhagat, Stuart Dalziel, and Megan Davies Wykes. Linden has studied the ventilation of buildings since 1990 and is a pioneer in the area. Previously Linden's aim was to make those buildings energy efficient and comfortable for their occupants, but in the light of the pandemic his work has taken on a new dimension. Since April he has been contributing to the Royal Society's Rapid Assistance in Modelling the Pandemic (RAMP) taskforce, which unites scientists and mathematicians in the effort to fight the pandemic.
Mixing or layering?
Evidence suggests that the virus which causes COVID-19 is transmitted mostly through larger droplets and smaller aerosols, which we expel when we breathe, talk, cough or laugh. These are hard to monitor, but the work of Linden and his colleagues confirms earlier research which suggests that CO2 can be used as a proxy. "Small respiratory aerosols containing the virus are transported along with the carbon dioxide produced by breathing, and are carried around a room by ventilation flows," explains Linden. "Insufficient ventilation can lead to high carbon dioxide concentration, which in turn could increase the risk of exposure to the virus."
What kind of ventilation is safest? Image: stux.
Many modern indoor spaces, such as offices, hospitals, or restaurants, use some sort of ventilation system. The way the ventilation is achieved varies — you could use either natural ventilation driven by wind and heat, or mechanical systems — but there are two main modes of operation. Mixing ventilation aims to keep the air in a space well-mixed and displacement ventilation creates a cooler lower zone and a warmer upper zone, with warm air being extracted through the top part of the room and cooler air supplied through vents near the floor.
When it comes to transmission of COVID-19, it seems obvious that mixing up the air isn't the way you'd want to go, and the work of Linden and his team broadly supports this idea. "[Mixing ventilation] is intended to keep everything airborne and stirred around, and if it works properly then that's what mixing ventilation does," Linden explains. "I think essentially that's not a good idea and there are better strategies you can adapt." Displacement ventilation appears to be such a strategy: the warm and potentially dangerous air we exhale will rise to the ceiling, where it can be extracted.
What Linden and his colleagues also showed, however, is that things aren't quite as simple as they might first seem. Ventilation systems aren't the only things that cause significant air flows in a room. Other factors — people moving around, the opening and closing of doors, and heat emanating from people's bodies or appliances — can also cause the air to move in ways you can't just ignore. This means that even with displacement ventilation you can run into trouble: when there are various heat sources in a room, exhaled breath can get trapped below the warm ceiling layer and breathed in again by others.
The exact behaviour of people's exhaled breath and its role in disease transmission is extremely difficult to predict, so Linden and his colleagues headed to the lab. They did this in the middle of the spring lockdown, when the fluid dynamics laboratory was the only part of the Centre for Mathematical Sciences at the University of Cambridge that was open, and only to a select few.
Breathing, talking, laughing
Even when a person is sitting still and holding their breath, their body heat produces a plume of warm air that rises to the ceiling. When the person starts breathing, or opens their mouth to talk, sing, cough or laugh, their exhaled breath produces a second plume. In terms of transmission, it's best for this second plume to be entrained by the main body plume to be carried to the ceiling with it.
Air is invisible, of course, but Linden and his team used an imaging technique that allows you to track warm air. "You can see the change in temperature and density when someone breathes out warm air – it refracts the light and you can measure it,"explains Bhagat.
The images the team produced are shown below. In the left hand image the person is sitting quietly breathing through their nose, in the middle one he is speaking at a normal volume, and in the right one he is laughing. In each image, you can also see the body plume rising up gently — and in each of the three cases, you can see that the exhaled plume isn't absorbed by the body plume.
Breathing, talking and laughing without a mask. Image from Effects of ventilation on the indoor spread of COVID-19 by Bhagat, Davies Wykes, Dalziel, and Linden. Journal of Fluid Mechanics, 903, F1.
This is in contrast to the images you get when the person is wearing a mask, shown below. "One thing we could clearly see is that one of the ways that masks work is by stopping the breath's momentum," said Linden.
"While pretty much all masks will have a certain amount of leakage through the top and sides, it doesn't matter that much, because slowing the momentum of any exhaled contaminants reduces the chance of any direct exchange of aerosols and droplets as the breath remains in the body's thermal plume and is carried upwards towards the ceiling. Additionally, masks stop larger droplets, and a three-layered mask decreases the amount of those contaminants that are recirculated through the room by ventilation."
Breathing, talking and laughing with a mask. Image from Effects of ventilation on the indoor spread of COVID-19 by Bhagat, Davies Wykes, Dalziel, and Linden. Journal of Fluid Mechanics, 903, F1.
Experiments meet mathematics
Experiments like these are hugely important, but they only form a part of the work of Linden and his team. Equally important are mathematical models that describe the behaviour of gasses and contaminants within them. An interesting example is the Wells-Riley equation, which estimates the expected number of people who become infected by sharing a room with people who have an airborne disease:
Here is the number of people in the room who are susceptible to the disease, and, loosely speaking, describes the total rate at which already infected occupants in the room emit infectious material, measures the average breathing rate per person, and the time period people are sharing the room. The number measures the ventilation rate of the room the room, that is, the rate at which fresh air enters it.
A close look at the equation reveals that the larger (the better the ventilation of the room) the smaller the number of people who become infected. The Wells-Riley equation assumes that the ventilation is uniform across the space, and as Linden and his team have shown, this isn’t usually the case in reality, as air flows created by people and appliances also matter. However, the Wells-Riley equation (along with many other relevant mathematical expressions) can form part of more complex models that describe real life more accurately.
A warning system
Linden and his colleagues stress that there's still more work to do on ventilation and COVID-19. For example, it would be good to know more about what happens to people's body plumes and exhaled breath as they move around a room. But the work done so far already carries an important message. Displacement ventilation systems, when properly set up, appear to be the better option, and face coverings are beneficial.
The research also suggests another interesting possibility. Since virus-laden aerosols behave like the CO2 we breathe out, the CO2 level in a room could provide a warning system. It can quite easily be measured, and when it's high, the risk of airborne infection is high too. "What we have in mind is something like a traffic light system," explains Linden. "But what we are not clear about yet is [which CO2 thresholds should mark the boundaries between green, amber and red]. So that's an area that still needs discussion."
For those of us without ventilation systems or ways of measuring CO2, the message is simple. When there are several people in a room, open the windows, keep your distance, and wear your masks.
About this article
Some of the quotes in this article are taken from Many ventilation systems may increase risk of COVID-19 exposure, study suggests, reproduced under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.